Resolve the second-pass review findings — comments undo via .trash recursion, search reach, refuse-don't-degrade paste

Thirteen findings cleared with the user (Redesign board: 3 Contradictions + 3 Gaps + 7 Minors → Resolved):

- User template store re-homes to the shared App Group container (09/02) — templates cross editions; App Group implementation card annotated mid-flight.
- Comment delete = move into comments/.trash/ (01/05/13) — the materialized-trash pattern one level down; no byte capture returns on any edition; purge at window close, copies strip it; 13's absolutes stay true.
- Find & search: card-window ⌘F covers the focused comments pane; board search re-ruled to all meaningful card content — comment bodies via a search-owned transient index when comments ship, attributes as they activate (04/01/05); scope options = WISHLIST #10.
- Comments pane visibility = one persisted app-wide bit, à la Show Trash — content-derived auto-show retired (05/11).
- Comment attachments author in-window: composer/inline-edit drop carve-outs + paperclip (05).
- Item-level copies sever remote/remote-state at every level; whole-board forks exempt (01).
- Paste refuses loudly, never degrades — degraded embedded-index.md fallback and its loss row retired; Finder's whole-or-nothing invariant adopted (04/12/02).
- Escape: composer moves focus out (never discards a draft); inline comment edit = Cancel (05/11).
- Minors: 05 three-pane changes bullet, 01 comments-UI parenthetical, 07 TOFU store naming, WISHLIST item 3 trash wording, README deferred-list now points at the findings board.

Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01CqjXB7ASoWtbyoGod68k97

DESIGN/04-interactions.md

@@ -25,7 +25,7 @@ Selection, drag & drop, keyboard, clipboard, search. This is where the old app s
 
 ## Clipboard
 
-- ⌘X/⌘C/⌘V on cards **and lanes** (resettled — lanes joined the clipboard so cross-board structure transfer has a keyboard path under the every-function contract; the cards-XOR-lanes selection rule means the clipboard holds cards or lanes, never both). Hybrid clipboard: pasteboard carries a JSON manifest + plain text; full folder snapshots staged in the shared App Group container (12-editions.md — so a copy in one edition pastes full-fidelity in the other) so paste reproduces the item byte-for-byte — cards, attachments and all — across boards. Each manifest entry embeds the full `index.md` as a staging-less fallback (a lane entry embeds its cards' too, attachment-less). **Staging lifecycle** (settled): snapshots are staged **eagerly at ⌘C/⌘X time** — copy captures the source as it is at the gesture, immune to later deletion or unmount — and the store holds at most the *current* copy: a new Lanework copy replaces the previous snapshot, and a sweep at launch and on each copy purges entries the pasteboard no longer references (another app taking the pasteboard orphans the snapshot; the next sweep collects it). The snapshot survives relaunch exactly as long as the pasteboard still points at it — a copy made before quitting pastes whole after restart. **A paste is an import boundary, so normalization applies** (settled 2026-07-28 — 01-storage-format.md's loose-file rule): loose files the staged snapshot carries beside a card's `index.md` land in the pasted card's `attachments/`, Finder-renamed on collision — nothing the snapshot preserved is dropped on arrival. **A degraded paste is loud, never silent** (the banner vocabulary — 02-architecture.md): if the staged snapshot is missing or unreadable at paste time, paste falls back to the embedded `index.md` — content intact, files absent — and a **loss row** (warning tone, user-dismissed) names what was lost with true totals, attachments and loose files alike, folding plurals ("Pasted 'Fix login' without its 3 attachments"; "Pasted 2 items without their 5 files" — BannerCenter owns the phrasing, the manifest records each entry's staged file count so the totals stay honest); the user never discovers an empty `attachments/` later. **The pasteboard is re-read lazily, and the brief lie is accepted** (settled): changeCount is checked on activation, on menu validation, and before paste — no timers; a background app taking the pasteboard while Lanework stays frontmost can leave Edit ▸ Paste enabled until the next check, and the paste itself re-validates and no-ops — nothing stale ever lands, which is the guarantee that matters.
+- ⌘X/⌘C/⌘V on cards **and lanes** (resettled — lanes joined the clipboard so cross-board structure transfer has a keyboard path under the every-function contract; the cards-XOR-lanes selection rule means the clipboard holds cards or lanes, never both). Hybrid clipboard: pasteboard carries a JSON manifest + plain text; full folder snapshots staged in the shared App Group container (12-editions.md — so a copy in one edition pastes full-fidelity in the other) so paste reproduces the item byte-for-byte — cards, attachments and all — across boards. Each manifest entry embeds the full `index.md` — identification metadata (menu validation, refusal wording, the plain-text flavor's source), **never a materialization source** since the 2026-07-29 refuse-don't-degrade ruling below (a lane entry embeds its cards' too). **Staging lifecycle** (settled): snapshots are staged **eagerly at ⌘C/⌘X time** — copy captures the source as it is at the gesture, immune to later deletion or unmount — and the store holds at most the *current* copy: a new Lanework copy replaces the previous snapshot, and a sweep at launch and on each copy purges entries the pasteboard no longer references (another app taking the pasteboard orphans the snapshot; the next sweep collects it). The snapshot survives relaunch exactly as long as the pasteboard still points at it — a copy made before quitting pastes whole after restart. **A paste is an import boundary, so normalization applies** (settled 2026-07-28 — 01-storage-format.md's loose-file rule): loose files the staged snapshot carries beside a card's `index.md` land in the pasted card's `attachments/`, Finder-renamed on collision — nothing the snapshot preserved is dropped on arrival. **A paste whose staged snapshot is missing or unreadable refuses loudly — never degrades** (re-ruled 2026-07-29, retiring the degraded embedded-`index.md` fallback and its loss row; Finder's invariant adopted, and 01's leniency doctrine applied — proceed-partially-lose-a-little is never a verdict): the paste produces **nothing**, and a one-shot failure banner names it from the manifest's metadata ("The copied cards are no longer available" / "Couldn't paste 'Fix login' — the copied content is gone"; BannerCenter owns the phrasing). An item arrives **whole — index, attachments, loose files, and comments when they ship — or not at all**; a hollowed card is never materialized, so the loss-accounting problem (what didn't arrive, and whether the totals are honest) dissolves rather than being solved. The refusal is transactional — all-or-nothing for the whole paste, the copies-are-transactions posture (01). With eager staging and the shared-store sweep discipline this is a rare corner, not a flow: the refusal names it, and ⌘C again is the recovery. **The pasteboard is re-read lazily, and the brief lie is accepted** (settled): changeCount is checked on activation, on menu validation, and before paste — no timers; a background app taking the pasteboard while Lanework stays frontmost can leave Edit ▸ Paste enabled until the next check, and the paste itself re-validates and no-ops — nothing stale ever lands, which is the guarantee that matters.
 - **Cut is Finder-style deferred**: cut items dim in place until paste moves them; voided if another app takes the pasteboard or the source board closes; second paste materializes copies. **Deletion voids per item**: a cut item that is deleted (moved to the trash or destroyed) or vanishes externally before paste drops out of the pending cut — 02-architecture.md's UUID-set rule; transient state never resurrects what's gone — so paste moves only the survivors, and a cut voided down to nothing is simply void (paste disabled, no error).
 - Paste lands after the anchor card (or appends to a selected lane); a multi-selection anchors at its last member in flatten order — the ⌘N target rule's shared anchor (The map below). Copies keep `created` (a duplicate is a fork) and take fresh GUID/`order`/`modified`. **A trash selection never anchors paste** (settled — the ⌘N target rule's own wording, returned to the precedent it cites): ⌘V stays enabled and behaves exactly as with nothing selected — a card payload appends to the last-active lane, a lane payload lands at the board's right end; the trash is never the destination (▸ The trash), and a trashed card's live disk-lane never leaks in as "the selected card's lane".
 - **Lane paste** lands after the anchor lane — the selected lane, or the selected card's lane (several selected: the last, per the shared anchor rule); nothing selected = the board's right end. Semantics mirror the drag pair above exactly: a pasted *copy* takes fresh GUIDs throughout; a cut-paste is the ⌘-drag move — the folder moves whole (nothing lane-nested to strip or carry — the trash is board-level, resettled 2026-07-28). **Pasting into the source board is supported and is the within-board lane duplicate** (settled): fresh GUIDs apply as anywhere else, no menu-validation special case — the drag path deliberately lacks this operation (⌥ ignored on lane drags, above), the clipboard is its one home.
@@ -84,7 +84,7 @@ Custom shortcuts are **system-native, with no in-app remapping UI**: macOS's App
 
 ## Search
 
-- Search field invoked with ⌘F (the board toolbar's sole default item; removed from the toolbar, ⌘F surfaces it transiently — 03-board-ui.md ▸ Toolbar; in the **card window**, Edit ▸ Find is find-in-text instead — 05-card-window.md), live filter: cards whose title *and* body both miss the query animate out; case/diacritic-insensitive substring. Scope is **title + body only** (settled) — attachment filenames are not searched.
+- Search field invoked with ⌘F (the board toolbar's sole default item; removed from the toolbar, ⌘F surfaces it transiently — 03-board-ui.md ▸ Toolbar; in the **card window**, Edit ▸ Find is find-in-text instead — 05-card-window.md), live filter: cards whose title *and* body both miss the query animate out; case/diacritic-insensitive substring. Scope is **all card content the format makes meaningful** (re-ruled 2026-07-29, superseding title-plus-body-only): title + body today; **comment bodies join when comments ship** — via a search-owned transient comment index, never the snapshot: the first live-query keystroke kicks an async sweep of `comments/*/index.md` bodies (`.draft` and `comments/.trash/` excluded), kept fresh by the same FSEvents stream while a query is active and discarded when it clears — the board walk stays O(cards), 01's window-scoped read untouched; **attributes join as they activate** (title now; labels/tags and their kin are reserved, inert keys this version — nothing to search until a future version gives them life). Attachment filenames stay unsearched. Scope options (content vs attributes, either/or) are WISHLIST #10.
 - The filter is the single source of truth for "what's on the board": layout, drop zones, marquee, ranges, arrow nav, and lane count badges all read it. Hidden cards leave the selection; creating a card clears the search — creation's carve-out exists because a brand-new card must not be born invisible, and it is **stated by mechanism, not by gesture** (settled): *any* user-initiated creation on the board clears the query — ⌘N, Return-creation, the header button, empty-space double-click, paste, and Finder file drops alike — while foreign/agent-filed cards keep riding the live filter (02-architecture.md's derived-result rule). **Rename deliberately gets no carve-out**: a rename committed during an active search re-runs the predicate like any edit — a title that stops matching animates the card out and drops it from the selection, exactly as an agent's edit would; the filter stays a pure predicate with one exception, not two. **Escape is staged** (settled): in a non-empty field it clears the query, focus staying in the field; in an empty field it returns focus to the board; with *board* focus and an active search, one press clears the search and the full board returns — search takes Escape before its clear-selection meaning, which applies only when no search is active. **A lane the query empties keeps its slot** (settled): lanes are never filtered out — an all-misses lane stays on the board at its width with a 0 badge (the count reads the filter, 03-board-ui.md); the search filters cards, and the board's structure is not a search result. **A leaving card stays input-reachable for its out-transition** (settled): marquee and arrow targets deregister when the ~0.28 s animate-out ends, so a card mid-departure is briefly reachable while already out of the selection — accepted: it is literally on screen for that span, and closing the window would teach three input sites a predicate the layout already applied. **An open inline rename survives the filter hiding its card** (settled): the editor is a surface the filter doesn't reach — it stays open and focused, commits by UUID wherever the card lives, Escape abandons; keystrokes are never silently discarded for a card that still exists (the dirty-buffer courtesy), and the vanish-discard rule stays reserved for true liveness flips. The typed-query path can't even occur — focusing the search field is focus loss, which commits the rename first — so the rule covers foreign edits that stop the card matching.
 - **Dispatch while the search field is focused** (settled): the field is a *control*, not a content editor — the focused-editor lockdown (Grammar above) does not apply. Text-domain keys route to the field: ⌘A/⌘X/⌘C/⌘V act on the query, plain ⌫ edits the query and never reaches the board, horizontal arrows move the caret. **Every key with the field focused acts on the field — stock NSSearchField behavior, no pass-throughs** (settled): vertical arrows are caret movement, ⇧-arrows select query text, and **Return is a swallowed no-op** (the filter is live, there is nothing to submit — it never reaches the board's rename/create grammar). **Tab is the keep-filter path**: plain key-view traversal moves focus to the board with the query intact, and the whole board grammar (arrows, ⌥↑ escalation, Return, ⌘↩) then applies over the *filtered* board; ⌘F returns to the field. Board menu commands stay enabled and act on the board selection exactly as when the field is unfocused — ⌘N included (creating a card clears the search, above) — **except the caret-chord commands**: Move Left/Right ⌘←/⌘→ and the width pair ⌥⌘←/⌥⌘→ disable while the field is focused (Grammar above, caret-chords rule), so ⌘←/⌘→ stay line-start/end in the query even with a lane selected — and the Delete pair stays unambiguous by construction: plain ⌫ is query editing, ⌘⌫ is File ▸ Delete on the selection, and ⌘Z/⇧⌘Z are the field's own text undo, never git undo (06-history-undo.md ▸ Undo routing's control-class rule).