Files
lanework/Kanban/LiveStore/SelectionGrammar.swift
T
rzen f7c8088783 Lanes delete into the trash — rendering, grammar, drag, clipboard, a11y
Phase 2 completes the lanes-in-trash card. TrashEntry merges the
trash's two kinds by rank in exactly ONE place (ItemPath.resolve's
own merge deleted in favor of it — the three-merge-points finding
shrinks instead of growing). TrashLaneRowView renders the opaque
row — tertiary plate, level-default lane glyph never the lane's own
icon, title + card count, no accents, no expansion; the column badge
counts rendered rows. Selection grammar: kind-homogeneous trash
selections — ranges skip the other kind, ⇧-extension stops at the
kind boundary, plain arrows walk the merged order, marquee stays
card-only (now load-bearing: rows register frames for arrows),
Select All card-scoped; successor-on-purge crosses kinds like
navigation as the interim for open Gap 7b5cbc90. Drag: TrashDrop
accepts lane sessions (drop on shown trash deletes), restoreLanes
routes a trash-sourced strip drop as an arrival-ranked within-board
move with an undo step. Clipboard: ⌘X/⌘V lane restore via opaque
lane subjects; fixed boardRoot(ofLaneFolder:) returning .trash as
the root — a same-board restore looked like an import and would
have reminted the lane it was restoring (pinned by test). A11y:
row = one flattened "title, deleted lane, N cards" element with
Delete/Reveal actions; BoardDiff crossings read lanes as
deleted/restored, shown-trash churn digested at row level. Agent
guide stays v7 — the literal already teaches lanes-trash-by-move
and kind stamping; drift-guard pins those lines. README trash
paragraph notes lanes.

Both schemes 1893 tests / 322 suites green.

Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01SR4XGjmBE16ZUYWpfFHXwY
2026-07-30 17:04:30 -04:00

530 lines
28 KiB
Swift

import CoreGraphics
import Foundation
// MARK: - What a click names
/// Which of the board's two selectable levels an item is — 04-interactions.md § Selection's
/// **cards XOR lanes** axis, named so the grammar can compare it rather than infer it per branch.
///
/// It is deliberately *not* stored anywhere: a selection is a set of ids and nothing else
/// (`ItemReferenceSet`), so the kind of a selection is always re-derived from the snapshot. Storing
/// it would be a second answer to a question the snapshot can always answer, and one that a reload
/// could falsify.
///
/// The **one** place a kind is written down is the clipboard manifest, which has no snapshot to
/// re-derive it from — "the cards-XOR-lanes selection rule means the clipboard holds cards or lanes,
/// never both" (04-interactions.md ▸ Clipboard). Hence `String`-backed and `Codable`: those raw
/// spellings are pasteboard API, decoded after a relaunch, and they are the case names so there is
/// no second vocabulary to keep in step.
public enum SelectionKind: String, Codable, Sendable, Equatable {
case card
case lane
}
/// What a pointer click names: an item, its level, and the container the surface it was clicked on
/// belongs to.
///
/// The **container is the surface's, not the item's** — a card face is always `.board` and a trash
/// row is always `.trash`, because that is what the user clicked. A click on a surface whose item
/// crossed containers a moment ago simply selects nothing the next reload will keep, which is the
/// ordinary vanish rule and not a case for this type to model.
public struct SelectionTarget: Sendable, Equatable {
public var id: ItemID
public var kind: SelectionKind
public var container: ItemContainer
public init(id: ItemID, kind: SelectionKind, container: ItemContainer) {
self.id = id
self.kind = kind
self.container = container
}
}
/// The modifier a click carried — 04-interactions.md § Selection's three-way grammar ("click
/// selects; ⌘-click toggles; ⇧-click range-extends").
///
/// Three cases rather than an `OptionSet`, because the design gives ⌘ and ⇧ *no* combined meaning:
/// AppKit hands us both flags when both keys are down, and the grammar picks one. `ClickModifier`
/// is where that choice is made once (`ClickModifier.current`), so no call site re-decides it.
public enum ClickModifier: Sendable, Equatable {
case plain
case command
case shift
}
// MARK: - SelectionGrammar
/// 04-interactions.md § Selection's pointer grammar, plus § The trash's extensions to it, as a pure
/// function of the click, the current selection, the anchor, and the snapshot
/// (`SelectionGrammarTests`).
///
/// **Homogeneity is the invariant, and it is enforced here or nowhere.** The selection is
/// homogeneous on **two** axes — cards XOR lanes (§ Selection) and board XOR trash (§ The trash's
/// "single container rule replacing the old liveness law") — and since lanes rejoined the trash
/// (2026-07-29) the kind axis simply reaches into the second container too: "a trash selection is
/// either cards or lane rows, kind-homogeneous like the live board's own grammar". Both axes are a
/// property of what a *click* is allowed to produce, so no outcome below is ever mixed: a modifier
/// that would cross an axis degrades to a replace, which is the only answer that keeps the invariant
/// true without silently dropping what the user asked for.
///
/// **Pure, for `NewCardTarget`'s reason**: the branches become lines of test rather than gestures to
/// drive, and the four surfaces that clicks arrive on (card face, lane header, lane empty space,
/// trash card) share one answer instead of four near-copies of it.
public enum SelectionGrammar {
/// What a click leaves behind: the new selection, the anchor a subsequent ⇧-click would range
/// from, and the head a subsequent arrow would step from.
///
/// The anchor is carried *out* rather than mutated in place because it is not derivable from the
/// selection — a ⇧-range replaces the whole set and deliberately leaves the anchor where it was,
/// so "the last plain or ⌘ click" is a memory of a gesture and only the gesture can update it
/// (`TransientBoardState.selectionAnchor`).
///
/// **The head is always the clicked item**, in every branch below — the ⇧-branch included, where
/// the anchor deliberately stays put. That asymmetry is the definition of the two:
/// `TransientBoardState.selectionHead` is where the *next* step starts, and a ⇧-click moves it
/// exactly as a plain one does.
public struct Outcome: Sendable, Equatable {
public var selection: ItemReferenceSet
public var anchor: ItemID?
public var head: ItemID?
public init(selection: ItemReferenceSet, anchor: ItemID?, head: ItemID? = nil) {
self.selection = selection
self.anchor = anchor
self.head = head
}
/// Nothing selected, nothing to range from, nowhere to step from — the toggle-off outcomes.
static let cleared = Outcome(selection: .empty, anchor: nil, head: nil)
}
/// The grammar, one call.
///
/// - Parameters:
/// - target: what was clicked, with the surface's container (see `SelectionTarget`).
/// - modifier: the effective modifier, already reduced to one of three (`ClickModifier`).
/// - selection: the board's current selection.
/// - anchor: the range origin — `TransientBoardState.selectionAnchor`.
/// - snapshot: the board as it is now; every order list and every kind is derived from it.
/// - togglesOnRepeat: **the lane's click-again-to-unselect**, and only the lane's
/// (04-interactions.md § Selection: "single click selects the lane (click again to
/// unselect)", and the header "toggles like empty space (settled)"). A card face passes
/// `false`: Finder does not deselect a file by clicking it twice, and neither do we.
/// - filter: the live search filter (04 § Search). Only the ⇧-branch reads it — a range walks
/// what is *on the board*, which under a search is the survivors — because the other two
/// name their target outright and a click on something the user can see needs no permission
/// from the predicate.
public static func click(
_ target: SelectionTarget,
modifier: ClickModifier,
selection: ItemReferenceSet,
anchor: ItemID?,
snapshot: BoardModel,
togglesOnRepeat: Bool = false,
filter: SearchFilter = .inactive
) -> Outcome {
switch modifier {
case .plain:
return plain(target, selection: selection, togglesOnRepeat: togglesOnRepeat)
case .command:
return command(target, selection: selection, snapshot: snapshot)
case .shift:
return shift(target, selection: selection, anchor: anchor, snapshot: snapshot, filter: filter)
}
}
// MARK: - The three branches
/// **Plain**: the selection becomes exactly what was clicked, and the click becomes the anchor.
///
/// The one exception is `togglesOnRepeat`, and it tests for *sole membership* rather than mere
/// containment: a lane click that lands inside a multi-lane selection narrows it to that lane
/// (replace), because "click again to unselect" is about the lane the user already had, not
/// about wiping a selection they built with ⌘.
private static func plain(
_ target: SelectionTarget,
selection: ItemReferenceSet,
togglesOnRepeat: Bool
) -> Outcome {
if togglesOnRepeat, selection.container == target.container, selection.ids == [target.id] {
return .cleared
}
return Outcome(
selection: ItemReferenceSet(ids: [target.id], container: target.container),
anchor: target.id,
head: target.id
)
}
/// **⌘-click toggles** — but only *within* a homogeneous set. Crossing either axis (a card
/// clicked while lanes are selected, a trash card clicked while board cards are) is not a mixed
/// selection and not a refusal: it is a **replace**, the same outcome a plain click would give,
/// because the click unambiguously names a new set of one.
///
/// The current kind is derived from the snapshot rather than remembered (`kind(of:in:)`); a
/// selection whose members all name nothing the board renders counts as empty, so a ⌘-click
/// after a foreign delete starts a fresh set rather than extending a ghost.
private static func command(
_ target: SelectionTarget,
selection: ItemReferenceSet,
snapshot: BoardModel
) -> Outcome {
guard selection.container == target.container,
let current = kind(of: selection, in: snapshot),
current == target.kind
else {
return plain(target, selection: selection, togglesOnRepeat: false)
}
var ids = selection.ids
if ids.remove(target.id) == nil {
ids.insert(target.id)
} else if ids.isEmpty {
// The last member toggled out: nothing is selected, so there is nothing to range from.
return .cleared
}
return Outcome(
selection: ItemReferenceSet(ids: ids, container: target.container),
anchor: target.id,
head: target.id
)
}
/// **⇧-click range-extends from the anchor**, Finder-list style: the whole range replaces the
/// selection, and the anchor stays where it is so successive ⇧-clicks sweep out from the same
/// origin rather than walking it along.
///
/// The anchor is valid **iff both it and the target sit in the same order list** — which folds
/// the nil anchor, the vanished anchor, and every axis crossing into one test, since a list is
/// exactly one (container, kind) pair. An invalid anchor makes the click a plain one, never a no-op:
/// the keyboard's ⇧-arrow goes inert at a boundary because its next step is ambiguous, while a
/// click names an unambiguous target and so always has something to do.
private static func shift(
_ target: SelectionTarget,
selection: ItemReferenceSet,
anchor: ItemID?,
snapshot: BoardModel,
filter: SearchFilter
) -> Outcome {
guard let anchor,
let span = range(
from: anchor,
to: target.id,
kind: target.kind,
in: target.container,
snapshot: snapshot,
filter: filter
)
else {
return plain(target, selection: selection, togglesOnRepeat: false)
}
return Outcome(
selection: ItemReferenceSet(ids: span, container: target.container),
anchor: anchor,
head: target.id
)
}
/// The ids between two items in one order list, inclusive — **the span both extension gestures
/// select**, ⇧-click and ⇧-arrow alike.
///
/// It is a function rather than a branch inside `shift` because the keyboard needs the identical
/// answer: "a ⇧-arrow extends" (04-interactions.md ▸ Grammar) means exactly the range a ⇧-click
/// to the same item would produce, and two implementations of one span is two chances for the
/// pointer and the keyboard to disagree about what a range is.
///
/// **`nil` means the two do not share a list**, which folds the vanished endpoint, the nil
/// anchor's caller-side absence, and every axis crossing into one test — a list is exactly one
/// (container, kind) pair. The callers differ on what they do with that: a click degrades to a
/// plain click (it names an unambiguous target), while a ⇧-arrow goes inert (its next step is
/// ambiguous).
///
/// **A filtered endpoint is a missing one**, which needs no rule of its own: a card the search
/// hid is absent from the list, so a range aimed at it answers `nil` and each caller degrades
/// exactly as it does for a card an agent deleted. The span between two *visible* endpoints
/// likewise collects only survivors — 04 § Search's "ranges … read [the filter]".
public static func range(
from: ItemID,
to: ItemID,
kind: SelectionKind,
in container: ItemContainer,
snapshot: BoardModel,
filter: SearchFilter = .inactive
) -> Set<ItemID>? {
let list = order(of: kind, in: container, snapshot: snapshot, filter: filter)
guard let start = list.firstIndex(of: from), let end = list.firstIndex(of: to) else { return nil }
return Set(start <= end ? list[start...end] : list[end...start])
}
// MARK: - The order lists
/// The list a ⇧-range walks for one (container, kind) pair — **the single place a "what's on the
/// board, in what order" question is answered** for the pointer.
///
/// **The search filter threads in here and in `MarqueeTargetRegistry`'s membership, and nowhere
/// else** — the filter "is the single source of truth for what's on the board … ranges … all
/// read it" (04-interactions.md § Search), and every range, every Select All and every arrow
/// walk is stated in terms of these lists, so one parameter narrows all of them together.
///
/// It defaults to `.inactive` so the many callers with no query in hand (the drag's flatten
/// order, a lane-index lookup, the successor's container) read exactly as they did before the
/// filter existed; the callers that *are* the board's input grammar pass the store's query.
///
/// **The lane list takes no filter**, because a card query hides no *live* lane — see
/// `SearchFilter`. **The trash's lane list is filtered like its cards**, and that asymmetry is
/// the opaque unit's own (03-board-ui.md § Trash: "The row matches the search filter by lane
/// title only") — a trashed lane is a row in a column, not a container a query can empty.
///
/// **Both trash lists are kind-narrowed slices of one order** (`BoardModel.trashEntries`,
/// 04-interactions.md ▸ The trash: "⇧-click ranges skip rows of the other kind"), which is what
/// makes a range skip the other kind rather than needing a rule that says so: a list is exactly
/// one (container, kind) pair, and the rows in between simply are not in it.
public static func order(
of kind: SelectionKind,
in container: ItemContainer,
snapshot: BoardModel,
filter: SearchFilter = .inactive
) -> [ItemID] {
switch (container, kind) {
case (.board, .card): boardCards(in: snapshot, filter: filter)
case (.board, .lane): lanes(in: snapshot)
case (.trash, .card): trashCards(in: snapshot, filter: filter)
case (.trash, .lane): trashLanes(in: snapshot, filter: filter)
}
}
/// The board's cards in **flatten order** — "lane `order` first, then card `order` (a cross-lane
/// selection flattens left-to-right, top-to-bottom)", the multi-drag order the ⌘N target rule
/// and paste anchoring already share (04-interactions.md ▸ Drag and drop, ▸ The map).
///
/// The snapshot's arrays are already in display order (`Ranks.sortedForDisplay`), so the flatten
/// is one walk — `NewCardTarget.resolve`'s walk, in list form.
///
/// **The filter narrows the walk in place**, which is what makes a search-time ⇧-range and
/// Select All read the same board the masonry drew: `LaneView.renderedCards` applies the same
/// predicate to the same cards, one lane at a time, and this is that collection flattened.
public static func boardCards(in snapshot: BoardModel, filter: SearchFilter = .inactive) -> [ItemID] {
var ids: [ItemID] = []
for lane in snapshot.lanes {
for card in lane.cards where filter.matches(card) {
ids.append(card.id)
}
}
return ids
}
/// The board's lanes, left to right.
///
/// **No search filter, deliberately**: 04 § Search filters *cards*, and a lane whose body the
/// query empties is still a lane on the board — the width division is layout, and the badge
/// showing `0` is the honest report. So the lane domain's ranges, arrows and moves are the one
/// part of the board grammar a search does not narrow.
public static func lanes(in snapshot: BoardModel) -> [ItemID] {
snapshot.lanes.map(\.id)
}
/// The trash's cards, top to bottom — `snapshot.trash` itself, which the loader already sorted
/// by `order` like any lane's children (03-board-ui.md § Trash: "the trash sorts by `order` like
/// any lane", newest-first falling out of the ranks rather than a timestamp sort).
///
/// **Filtered like any lane** (03-board-ui.md § Trash: "shown, its cards participate in the
/// filter exactly like any other card") — the same predicate `TrashLaneView` applies to the same
/// cards, so a trash-side range walks exactly what the column is showing.
public static func trashCards(in snapshot: BoardModel, filter: SearchFilter = .inactive) -> [ItemID] {
snapshot.trash.filter { filter.matches($0) }.map(\.id)
}
/// The trash's **lane rows**, top to bottom — the opaque units (03-board-ui.md § Trash, lanes
/// rejoined 2026-07-29), filtered by title alone (`SearchFilter.matches(_ lane:)`).
///
/// Its own list rather than a kind flag on `trashCards` because that is what an order list *is*
/// here: one (container, kind) pair, and the pair is what a ⇧-range walks. The rows' positions
/// among the cards are `trashRows`' business.
public static func trashLanes(in snapshot: BoardModel, filter: SearchFilter = .inactive) -> [ItemID] {
snapshot.trashedLanes.filter { filter.matches($0) }.map(\.id)
}
/// **Every row the trash column shows, both kinds, in rank order** — what *navigation* walks
/// (04-interactions.md ▸ The trash: "inside, plain arrows walk every row, card and lane row
/// alike (navigation crosses kinds)").
///
/// The deliberate counterpart to the two lists above: extension and ranging are per-kind, so
/// they stop at a kind boundary, while navigation is over the column as drawn and crosses it.
/// One merge for both — `BoardModel.trashEntries`.
public static func trashRows(in snapshot: BoardModel, filter: SearchFilter = .inactive) -> [ItemID] {
snapshot.trashEntries.filter { filter.matches($0) }.map(\.id)
}
// MARK: - The current selection's kind
/// Which level the selection holds, or `nil` when it holds nothing its container renders.
///
/// **Any member answers, because the set is homogeneous** — but the walk is the snapshot's order
/// rather than the set's iteration order, so the answer is deterministic even for a set that
/// somehow was not. Members that name nothing are ignored, and a set of only such members reads
/// as empty: a selection the next reload will drop must not decide what a click does now.
///
/// **The trash answers for both kinds** (04-interactions.md ▸ The trash, lanes rejoined
/// 2026-07-29: "a trash selection is either cards or lane rows, kind-homogeneous like the live
/// board's own grammar"), walked in the column's own rank order so a set that somehow held both
/// answers by what is topmost rather than by array iteration order.
public static func kind(of selection: ItemReferenceSet, in snapshot: BoardModel) -> SelectionKind? {
guard !selection.isEmpty else { return nil }
switch selection.container {
case .trash:
return snapshot.trashEntries.first { selection.ids.contains($0.id) }?.kind
case .board:
for lane in snapshot.lanes {
if selection.ids.contains(lane.id) { return .lane }
if lane.cards.contains(where: { selection.ids.contains($0.id) }) { return .card }
}
return nil
}
}
// MARK: - Successor on delete
/// What ⌫ selects after deleting `ids` — 04-interactions.md ▸ The map's Finder-style
/// successor sibling, as a pure function of the **pre-write** snapshot.
///
/// > Selection moves to the deleted item's successor sibling, Finder-style (next card in the
/// > lane, next lane on the board; the last sibling's predecessor otherwise; empty container =
/// > nothing selected) — repeated ⌫ walks down a lane.
///
/// Three decisions the wording implies and this states:
///
/// - **The container is the *last* deleted item's**, in flatten order — the same "last member"
/// the ⌘N target rule and paste anchoring already share. A selection spanning lanes therefore
/// lands in the rightmost/bottom-most one, which is where the user was working.
/// - **The survivor search is forward first, then backward**: the first surviving sibling *after*
/// the last deleted position, else the last surviving sibling *before* the first deleted one.
/// Forward is what makes repeated ⌫ walk down a lane rather than bouncing.
/// - **`nil` is a legitimate answer** — an emptied container selects nothing, and the caller
/// clears.
///
/// **Both stagings of Delete get one** (04, resettled 2026-07-28 — "one Delete vocabulary,
/// staged by place"): `container` says which side the gesture ran on, and the trash walks its own
/// ordered rows exactly as a lane walks its own cards. The permanent delete is as deliberate an
/// act as the move-to-trash, so it keeps the repeatable-keystroke property the rule exists for.
/// **The trash's own successor crosses kinds** — an interim, and the branch below says why.
///
/// **Deliberate deletes only.** External vanishing never picks a successor (02-architecture.md's
/// reload-survival rule: "the selection just shrinks"), which is why this is called by
/// `BoardStore`'s delete paths and by nothing on the reload path.
///
/// **The container is what the surface is *showing*.** Under a search the successor must be a
/// card the user can see — picking a hidden neighbour would hand the selection straight back to
/// `constrainToSearch(in:)` to drop, which is a deselect wearing a successor's clothes. So the
/// filter narrows the container, and repeated ⌫ walks down the *filtered* lane.
public static func successor(
afterDeleting ids: Set<ItemID>,
in container: ItemContainer = .board,
snapshot: BoardModel,
filter: SearchFilter = .inactive
) -> ItemID? {
guard !ids.isEmpty else { return nil }
let selection = ItemReferenceSet(ids: ids, container: container)
guard let kind = kind(of: selection, in: snapshot) else { return nil }
let siblings: [ItemID]
switch (container, kind) {
case (.trash, _):
// **The siblings are every row, both kinds** — the interim answer to an open gap. 04
// ▸ The trash settles navigation (plain arrows cross kinds) and extension (⇧-arrows stop
// at the kind boundary) for the trash's two kinds, but says nothing about which row the
// *successor* lands on after a lane row is purged. Until that is ruled, this follows
// navigation rather than extension: the successor is the next row down the column
// whatever its kind, so a purge never strands the selection with nothing selected while
// rows the user can see sit right below it. The conservative direction — the alternative
// (kind-scoped siblings) clears the selection whenever the purged row was its kind's
// last, which is a deselect wearing a successor's clothes.
siblings = trashRows(in: snapshot, filter: filter)
case (.board, .lane):
siblings = lanes(in: snapshot)
case (.board, .card):
// The last selected card in flatten order names the lane; its lane's rendered cards are
// the container the successor is drawn from.
guard let last = boardCards(in: snapshot, filter: filter).last(where: { ids.contains($0) }),
let lane = snapshot.lanes.first(where: { lane in
lane.cards.contains { $0.id == last }
})
else { return nil }
siblings = lane.cards.filter { filter.matches($0) }.map(\.id)
}
let doomed = siblings.indices.filter { ids.contains(siblings[$0]) }
guard let first = doomed.first, let last = doomed.last else { return nil }
if let after = siblings[(last + 1)...].first(where: { !ids.contains($0) }) { return after }
return siblings[..<first].last { !ids.contains($0) }
}
}
// MARK: - The rubber band
/// One item the marquee can sweep: its identity, its level, its container, and where it is drawn.
///
/// The frame is in the board strip's coordinate space (`BoardView.stripSpace`) and is **registered
/// by the view that draws it** (`MarqueeTargetRegistry`) rather than computed here: the masonry's
/// geometry is the layout's own answer, and re-deriving it would be a second one.
public struct MarqueeTarget: Sendable, Equatable {
public var id: ItemID
public var kind: SelectionKind
public var container: ItemContainer
public var frame: CGRect
public init(id: ItemID, kind: SelectionKind, container: ItemContainer, frame: CGRect) {
self.id = id
self.kind = kind
self.container = container
self.frame = frame
}
}
/// What a rubber band selects, as a pure function of the band, the drawn frames, and the container
/// the band started in (`SelectionGrammarTests`).
///
/// The two rules it exists to state, both 04-interactions.md's:
///
/// - **The band stays on the side of the boundary it started on** (▸ The trash), which is why
/// `container` is a parameter rather than something derived from what the rect happens to touch: a
/// band begun on the board and dragged over the trash column selects board cards and nothing else.
/// - **The band never selects lanes** (§ Selection gives it to cards: "click-drag rubber-bands
/// across lanes" — across them, not over them). A live lane is never registered as a target at
/// all; a **trashed lane row is**, because the arrows navigate by the same frames
/// (`NavigationMath`) and the band's begin guard reads them too — so the kind filter below is
/// load-bearing rather than belt over braces.
///
/// **The kind filter is the whole of the rule, in both containers**: "the rubber band stays on the
/// side it started on and selects cards only (as the board marquee does); lane rows join by click
/// grammar" (04-interactions.md ▸ The trash, re-affirmed 2026-07-29). A band never has to break a
/// tie between a card and a lane row, because a lane row is not in the answer whatever it sweeps.
public enum MarqueeMath {
/// The ids `rect` sweeps.
public static func selection(
rect: CGRect,
targets: [MarqueeTarget],
in container: ItemContainer
) -> Set<ItemID> {
Set(
targets.lazy
.filter { $0.container == container && $0.kind == .card && rect.intersects($0.frame) }
.map(\.id)
)
}
/// Which of two drawn rows is "higher" — top edge, then leading edge, then identity.
///
/// Total rather than merely correct-for-a-column: two rows sharing a top edge must still order
/// the same way twice.
///
/// Used by `NavigationMath`, which breaks its score ties with it: two candidates that a metric
/// cannot separate must still be separated the same way twice.
static func isAbove(_ lhs: MarqueeTarget, _ rhs: MarqueeTarget) -> Bool {
if lhs.frame.minY != rhs.frame.minY { return lhs.frame.minY < rhs.frame.minY }
if lhs.frame.minX != rhs.frame.minX { return lhs.frame.minX < rhs.frame.minX }
return lhs.id.rawValue < rhs.id.rawValue
}
}