site: copy edit — 0 pieces tightened, 1 factual wording mismatch resolved
This commit is contained in:
@@ -4491,3 +4491,17 @@ Amazon: n-a (Australian maker, direct-only).
|
|||||||
- **mac-racken-bridge** was the fourth-ranked candidate and the closest call — a genuinely moving story with a clean hero. Held for one reason: the whole piece rests on Sergeant James Dougal MacRacken and the plaque's wording, and the sources for both are an Atlas Obscura entry and, presumably, the plaque itself. A review that cannot check a name and a unit number against anything but the entry it came from is a paraphrase, not a review. Worth graduating if the 315th Engineer Combat Battalion's records or a French municipal page can be found; a good candidate for a thin day with time to dig.
|
- **mac-racken-bridge** was the fourth-ranked candidate and the closest call — a genuinely moving story with a clean hero. Held for one reason: the whole piece rests on Sergeant James Dougal MacRacken and the plaque's wording, and the sources for both are an Atlas Obscura entry and, presumably, the plaque itself. A review that cannot check a name and a unit number against anything but the entry it came from is a paraphrase, not a review. Worth graduating if the 315th Engineer Combat Battalion's records or a French municipal page can be found; a good candidate for a thin day with time to dig.
|
||||||
- **patterns-in-nature-philip-ball** clears the bar comfortably and was held only because a book review wants the book, and this one was verified from the publisher's page rather than read.
|
- **patterns-in-nature-philip-ball** clears the bar comfortably and was held only because a book review wants the book, and this one was verified from the publisher's page rather than read.
|
||||||
- **portraits-of-trees-chestnuts** and **maratac-deep-cover-clip-pouch** both hold up as finds; neither has enough beyond the find body to justify 300 more words.
|
- **portraits-of-trees-chestnuts** and **maratac-deep-cover-clip-pouch** both hold up as finds; neither has enough beyond the find body to justify 300 more words.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
## 2026-07-29 — copy edit
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
Fresh-eyes sonnet subagent over all 18 pieces of prose written this run (14 find bodies, 1 bundle blurb + intro, 3 review bodies). **No prose changes — fourth consecutive clean run — and, as on 07-28, the pass still earned its keep by catching something outside its own remit.**
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
The subagent measured rather than estimated: find bodies 62–79 words against the 40–90 budget, the bundle intro one sentence at 51 words, reviews at 406 / 426 / 431 including the lead blockquote (329 / 355 / 359 without) against 250–450. It swept all 18 files for ad-copy tells and found none.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
**The catch.** It flagged a wording mismatch between two pieces about the same object and correctly declined to fix it: the `giant-d20-kit` **find** calls the numerals a "cut-and-stick sheet" while the **review** called it a "peel-and-place sheet". Its reasoning for not touching it was exactly right — deciding which phrase is correct is a factual call, not a prose one. Resolved in the main session in favour of the find: Lumin's own product listing says "Cut 'n' stick foam number sheet", so the review was wrong and is now aligned. One word, and the right process.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
It also surfaced two borderline lines it chose not to touch and was right about both: `beakdown`'s "Loads instantly, no account, no install" (terse feature cadence, but every clause is a verifiable fact, and it matches the Maratac find's established rhythm), and the LEGO review's "a party trick with a very good punchline" (mildly evaluative, but anchored to a specific mechanism rather than floating).
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
**Spot-check honoured rather than skipped**, per the standing 07-25 instruction. Three pieces the subagent passed — `mac-racken-bridge`, `hot-hand-project` and `withsay` — were re-counted by hand in the main session at 76 / 79 / 62 words, matching the subagent's figures **exactly**, as did the bundle intro at 51. An independent grep for ad-copy tells across all 18 files returned nothing. The streak is real, not generous grading.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
One format exception recorded so it is not re-litigated: `joke-broken-pizza` is 10 words against a 40–90 budget. The subagent flagged it, judged that padding a dad joke to 40 words would destroy it, and left it. Correct — the joke-find format has always been the setup and the punchline and nothing else.
|
||||||
|
|||||||
@@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ import hero from './hero.jpg';
|
|||||||
|
|
||||||
> A twenty-sided die is twenty triangles that have to meet at exactly the right angle, twelve times over. This kit's entire design problem is getting a beginner to that angle without a workshop.
|
> A twenty-sided die is twenty triangles that have to meet at exactly the right angle, twelve times over. This kit's entire design problem is getting a beginner to that angle without a workshop.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
The answer is the two cutters. Foam-smithing normally means freehanding a bevel with a craft knife and accepting that your joins will gap; Lumin's ships a custom bevel cutter for each hand, so the cut runs the same way regardless of which one you favour, and the edges close. Everything else in the box exists to remove a decision: twenty EVA foam triangles pre-cut, one spare, a pack of blades, and cut-and-stick foam for the 32 edges and 32 corners. The numbers arrive as a peel-and-place sheet in your choice of four fonts, one of them a proper blackletter. There is no glue anywhere in the kit, which is the line that makes it a Sunday rather than a project.
|
The answer is the two cutters. Foam-smithing normally means freehanding a bevel with a craft knife and accepting that your joins will gap; Lumin's ships a custom bevel cutter for each hand, so the cut runs the same way regardless of which one you favour, and the edges close. Everything else in the box exists to remove a decision: twenty EVA foam triangles pre-cut, one spare, a pack of blades, and cut-and-stick foam for the 32 edges and 32 corners. The numbers arrive on a cut-and-stick sheet in your choice of four fonts, one of them a proper blackletter. There is no glue anywhere in the kit, which is the line that makes it a Sunday rather than a project.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
Three sizes, priced 112, 149 and 239 on the Australian maker's own storefront, under the names Large, Extra Large and Gargantuan. What the listing does not include is a single dimension for any of them. The size comparison is a photograph of all three on a workbench with a banana in front, an arrow, and the caption "banana for scale" — which is either an oversight or a very confident piece of copywriting, and having seen the picture, it is the second one.
|
Three sizes, priced 112, 149 and 239 on the Australian maker's own storefront, under the names Large, Extra Large and Gargantuan. What the listing does not include is a single dimension for any of them. The size comparison is a photograph of all three on a workbench with a banana in front, an arrow, and the caption "banana for scale" — which is either an oversight or a very confident piece of copywriting, and having seen the picture, it is the second one.
|
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
|||||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user